Saving the Present at the Cost of the Past?

In the Summer 2012 issue of Nebraska History, Daniel Spegel explains the circumstances and powers that resulted in the largest ever demolition of a district listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The fate of Omaha’s Jobbers Canyon district played out in a public debate that drew national attention.

Demolition of the Trimble Brothers Building
Demolition of the Trimble Brothers Building, 802 Jackson Street. The demolition of Jobbers Canyon began following an April 13, 1988 court ruling and continued into 1989. Photo by Lynn Meyer, City of Omaha Planning Department.

Consisting of 22 historically contributing warehouses and four noncontributing buildings, Jobbers Canyon covered 6.25 blocks of downtown Omaha. Built at the turn of the twentieth century, Jobbers Canyon received its nickname because of the urban canyon created by the imposing structures. The buildings were prime examples of changing architecture, and also represented Omaha’s place as “the largest jobbing and manufacturing market in the territory.” In1986 the Nebraska State Historical Preservation Board unanimously approved the nomination of Jobbers Canyon to the National Register of Historic Places, and the National Park Service approved the nomination on December 4 of that year. Little did anyone know that just months later the buildings’ existence would be in jeopardy.

Jobbers Canyon, South Ninth Street
Looking north along the 400 block of South Ninth Street (between Harney and Howard) in1986. the Creighton Block is on the right; the John Deere Plow Company Building is on the left. Photo by Lynn Meyer, City of Omaha Planning Department.

When ConAgra, a major downtown Omaha employer, decided in 1986 to build a new headquarters, the riverfront seemed like an ideal location. Unfortunately, ConAgra officials were unwilling to include the “big, ugly, red brick buildings,” in the renovation plan. Having seen the success of the Old Market, a plan was submitted to include the repurposed historic buildings, but was rejected. The economic health of downtown Omaha had been declining for years, and Omaha leaders feared that losing ConAgra to another part of town would doom the area as the city expanded. They began pushing for the destruction of Jobbers Canyon to make room for the campus ConAgra executives wanted.

Preservationists around the country were appalled. Many felt that converting the old buildings could revitalize downtown Omaha much better than building over them, and scolded Omaha leaders for their “collective greed and fear.”

In his narrative, Spegel explores the legal actions, debate, accusations of news bias, and behind-the-scenes maneuvers, creating a portrait of a city as it struggled to reconcile the value of history with economic and political pressures.

-Joy Carey, Editorial Assistant

FacebookDeliciousLinkedInTwitterStumbleUponGoogle BookmarksDiggLiveJournalShare
This entry was posted in Historic Preservation and Archeology, Nebraska History, Publications and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>