Tractor vs. Horses

Tractor in Ogallala, Neb., 1918. NSHS RG0716-34-5

Tractor in Ogallala, Neb., 1918. NSHS RG0716-34-5

Which is more economical for a farmer, a tractor or a team of horses? In the early years of tractors, the answer wasn’t obvious to everyone. A series of tractor shows in the Midwest from 1913 to 1919 encouraged the growth of power farming in the United States. Reynold M. Wik writes about it in a 1983 Nebraska History article.

The earliest tractors used steam power…

NSHS RG3358-355

NSHS RG3358-355

Above is a Buffalo-Pitts steam tractor and water wagon. The photo is undated, but the Buffalo-Pitts company (of Buffalo, N.Y.) sold their first steam traction engine in 1882.

The big steam engines were too expensive for most farmers. Use of tractors expanded as gasoline engines became more powerful and affordable. Tractor manufacturers competed against horses for many years, as shown by this 1932 Farmall brochure:


NSHS RG3358AM-4-8

“Farmall Tractors Plowed at Less Than Half the Cost of Plowing with Horses,” reads the headline on the back side of the brochure. Here’s a detail that breaks down the costs:


And here’s a photo of the tractor in the brochure, location unknown:

NSHS RG 3358-4-8

NSHS RG 3358-4-8


–David Bristow, Associate Director for Research and Publications

FacebookDeliciousLinkedInTwitterStumbleUponGoogle BookmarksDiggLiveJournalShare
This entry was posted in Nebraska History, Photograph Collection, Publications and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Tractor vs. Horses

  1. caterpillar tractors for sale says:

    On this subject kinda…, brings me back to my youth, when I was young I lived over a farm where all of the tractors had been green. I like Fendt but for some reason I’ve always liked Farmall. Anyawy I’m beginning to daydream now…great post I’ve given it a DIGG.Com for you.

  2. Brian Szafranski of Western NY says:

    That’s a beautiful photo of a Buffalo Pitts steam traction and water wagon. There aren’t a lot of photos of water wagons that were often used with steam tractors.

    This is probably a photo of a small Threshing Crew as it went from farm to farm taking care of the harvests.

    For more information on Buffalo Pitts, please check out my website:

    Thanks to the NSHS for sharing these photos with us!

Leave a Reply to caterpillar tractors for sale Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>